| 1859 Charles A Fuller 1 | 1861 John J. Worsham 4 | 1860 Lucius J. Polk 2 |
| 1865 Amasa S. Underwood 2 | 1866 John McClelland 1 | 1867 John Frizzell 1 |
| 1868 Joseph M. Towler 3 | 1869 0 | 1870 Achiles D Sears 8 |
| 1871 George S. Blackie 1 | 1872 Joseph B. Palmer 10 | 1873 George Mellersh 4 |
| 1874 Morton B. Howell 1 | 1875 Henry M. Aiken 9 | 1876 William R. Bulter 10 |
| 1877 Edward R. T. Worsham 4 | 1878 Wilber F. Foster 1 | 1879 George C. Conner 14 |
| 1880 Joe H. Fussell 3 | 1881 Benjamin F. Holler 15 | 1882 William D. Robinson 10 |
| 1883 William P. Robertson 13 | 1884 Gideon R. Gwynne 7 | 1885 John B. Nicklin 14 |
| 1886 Henry C. Hensley 1 | 1887 Charles W. Mosby 15 | 1888 Bamaliel B. Wislon 8 |
| 1889 William C. Smith 17 | 1890 Nathan S. Woodward 9 | 1891 Robert Pillow 3 |
| 1892 Thomas O. Morris 1 | 1893 Willam M. Brooks 4 | 1894 Charles H. Eastman 17 |
| 1895 Orion L. Hurlbut 14 | 1896 Robert W. Haynes 13 | 1897 William J. Ely 8 |
| 1898 Samuel B. Dow 9 | 1899 John K. Currier 16 | 1900 Robert R. Freeman 1 |
| 1901 William T. Hope 14 | 1902 James P. Hanner 11 | 1903 John W. Bailey 4 |
| 1904 A. N. Sloan 14 | 1905 J. C. Smith, Jr. 13 | 1906 C. H. Harvey 9 |
| 1907 Henry R. Brown 20 | 1908 John C. Kennedy 1 | 1909 Lampley G. Walker 14 |
| 1910 William H. Joyner 4 | 1911 Josiah C. Egleston 11 | 1912 William G. Sheen 19 |
| 1913 Charles C. Taylor 13 | 1914 William Bowen 9 | 1915 Hamilton F. Shoun 20 |
| 1916 James N. Thompson 15 | 1917 Newton C. Maney 10 | 1918 William P. Chandler 23 |
| 1919 Amos T. Hooker 14 | 1920 John H. Corbitt 1 | 1921 Dick G. Crabtree 14 |
| 1922 James H. Cardall 15 | 1923 James H. Swan 19 | 1924 Clarence C. Breese 11 |
| 1925 John M. Buckingham 4 | 1926 William T. Gerhardt 10 | 1927 Chauncey Mynderse 23 |
| 1928 J. J. B. Johnsonius 16 | 1929 George T. Wofford 25 | 1930 David L. Griffith 15 |
| 1931 Joseph T. Meadors 1 | 1932 Robert G. Jeffries 9 | 1933 Hamner W. Scott 18 |
| 1934 Henry L. Fox 10 | 1935 Carlisle W. Evans 21 | 1936 Frank C. Gifford 4 |
| 1937 Arch E. McClanahan 1 | 1938 Mack S. Harrison 15 | 1939 Clyde H. Wislon 23 |
| 1940 Joseph L. Hill 1 | 1941 Harry Green 32 | 1942 James W. Kerr 29 |
| 1943 T. Earl Beasley 11 | 1944 William F. Dickey 23 | 1945 Lewie R. Polk 31 |
| 1946 Amzie H. Kirkpatrick 7 | 1947 Luther R. Ault 25 | 1948 Martin M. Allen 13 |
| 1949 Joseph O. Price 1 | 1950 W. Vernon Gibson 28 | 1951 Warner L. Scott 29 |
| 1952 Paul R. Jarratt 1 | 1953 Thomas E. Doss 25 | 1954 William J. Sanders, Jr. 10 |
| 1955 E. Guy Frizzell 9 | 1956 Nicholas A. Bond 18 | 1957 Russell B. Tandy 7 |
| 1958 James E. Isley 33 | 1959 Clifford H. Stroh 4 | 1960 Coy E. Zachry 26 |
| 1961 Roy W. Epperson 34 | 1962 Kenneth Flanning 13 | 1963 Robert L. Ramey 14 |
| 1964 Paul A. Chapman 19 | 1965 Lowell G. Hays 15 | 1966 Thomas M. Coleman 1 |
| 1967 E. Leslie Webb Jr. 23 | 1968 B. Tate Dawkins, Jr. 31 | 1969 Hilton H. Usher 32 |
| 1970 J. Pierce McGinnis 22 | 1971 J. Pierce McGinnis 22 | 1972 J. L. Robert Fuller 18 |
| 1973 E. Lee-Roy Doty 33 | 1974 Spencer P. Johnson 8 | 1975 Louis D. Hudgings 4 |
| 1976 Leslie L. Farmer 1 | 1977 Ernest Edwards 21 | 1978 Daron McCutcheon 16 |
| 1979 James A. Buford 14 | 1980 William A. Gentry 9 | 1981 William S. Boyd 39 |
| 1982 Joseph O. Hinch 10 | 1983 William E. Trivett 19 | 1984 Fred T. Goddard 29 |
| 1985 A. B. Church Jr. 11 | 1986 Crampton H. Helms 22 | 1987 Charles L. Brooks 4 |
| 1988 L. Alvin Hill Sr. 1 | 1989 H. Carmi Price Sr. 25 | 1990 Roy S. Bowman 36 |
| 1991 O. Ray Eldridge 38 | 1992 Howard C. Manning 23 | 1993 Donald M. Smith 31 |
| 1994 Sid C. Dorris, III 1 | 1995 C. Randell Carrier 37 | 1996 Charles L. Welch 13 |
| 1997 Dickie W. Johnson 7 | 1998 W. Boyd Crowder 21 | 1999 George R. Green 4 |
| 2000 Roy C. Etherton 38 | 2001 Donald Clayman 33 | 2002 Ford Bonds 36 |
| 2003 Terry L. Plemons 14 | 2004 H K Jack Akard 9 | 2005 Everett E. Young 39 |
| 2006 James A Hafner 1 | 2007 Von Lewis 19 | 2008 Ray Lee Covey 29 |
| 2009 Robert Warren Waldron Sr 10 | 2010 Herbert Glenn Beck Jr. 22 | 2011 David A. White, Sr. 39 |
